Volume & Issue: Volume 2, Issue 2 - Serial Number 4, Summer 2026 
Number of Articles: 6

The United Nations Security Council and the International Criminal Court in Suppressing International Crimes: The Conflict of Dutifulness and Realism

Pages 1-39

https://doi.org/10.22034/law.2026.740700

Mohammad Ali Ardebili, Alireza Nourian

Abstract The independence of the International Criminal Court in relation to the Security Council is relative. On the one hand, the close relationship between the ICC and UN Security Council diminishes the quality and legitimacy of justice (suspension of the investigation or reversal of the Court's actions by the Council) and the other hand, without their cooperation or without pursuing justice through power-politics(referral of the situation by the Council to the Court), some of the most serious international crimes and their perpetrators would never be tried. The question of the present descriptive-analytical research is how to assess the relationship between a judicial institution and a political institution in the prosecution of international crimes? In response, while evaluating all aspects of the relationship under study, using the functional approach of the Rome Statute, namely establishing peace through punishing perpetrators of international crimes, and the methodological approach, namely interpreting existing legal rules and highlighting the legal relationships between these rules, the research findings show that while the Council can positively activate the jurisdiction of the ICC, it can negatively suspend the ICC's activities; So after twenty-four years since the establishment of the ICC and, consequently, its relationship with the Council, and considering the Council's claim to functional control over the ICC, rationalizing the balance of power in the Security Council and the ICC is more necessary than ever. Limiting the exercise of the veto right and revising the Obligatory abstention rule of Article 27 (3) of the UN Charter, considering the subject matter of the complaint for UN fact-finding mission, and the possibility of reviewing the legitimacy of the Security Council's interventions in light of the Control Criteria, the latter two of which are subject to amendment to Article 17 of the Statute or the adoption of a debatable amendment, have been put forward as suggestions.

Disgorgement Damages: A Comparative Study of the Possibility or Impossibility of Its Cumulation with Other Forms of Damages in Anglo-American Common Law (with Reflections on Iranian Law)

Pages 41-72

https://doi.org/10.22034/law.2026.738848

Shobeir Azadbakht

Abstract The traditional approach to civil liability has primarily focused on compensating and repairing the losses suffered by the victim (compensatory damages). However, in many instances, the violation of a right not only causes loss to the right-holder but also yields significant profits for the wrongdoer—a situation that classic compensation models cannot fully address. Amidst this, disgorgement of profits arising from a violation of rights has emerged as an exceptional, non-compensatory remedy, initially in Common Law and subsequently in contemporary legal literature. Utilizing a descriptive-analytical method and a comparative approach within English and American Common Law, this research examines the possibility or impossibility of cumulating this remedy with other forms of damage payment, whether compensatory or non-compensatory. The findings indicate that, compared to compensatory damages, disgorgement of profits is fundamentally an exceptional institution; if compensatory damages suffice to protect the victim’s rights, awarding disgorgement is unnecessary. At the same time, the unrestricted cumulation of these two remedies can lead to double recovery. Therefore, the appropriate solution in this area is awarding the higher amount or deducting the compensatory damages from the realized profits. Conversely, disgorgement of profits is considered cumulatable with non-compensatory damages, particularl punitive damages, as each serves a distinct function: disgorgement aims to strip the wrongdoer of unlawful gains, while punitive damages serve a punitive and deterrent purpose. Consequently, disgorgement of profits should be applied in a manner that prevents the wrongdoer’s unjust enrichment while simultaneously avoiding both double recovery and under-compensation.

Rereading the Effect of Insanity on the Implementation of Hadith Punishments in Imami Jurisprudence and Iranian Criminal Law

Pages 73-96

https://doi.org/10.22034/law.2026.742234

Morteza Bayat

Abstract The interference of the issue of insanity with the process of implementing hadd punishments is considered one of the important emerging issues in Imami jurisprudence and the field of Iranian criminal law, because contrary to the existing consensus regarding the removal of criminal responsibility during the commission of a crime, the situation of criminals who become insanity after the crime has occurred is a source of disagreement. The present study, by adopting a descriptive-analytical approach and by examining jurisprudential sources, narrative texts, and established regulations, seeks to answer the question: "What are the jurisprudential and legal foundations of dealing with subsequent insanity in the implementation of hadd punishments, and what solution has the Iranian legislator chosen for it?" The analysis of jurisprudential views indicates three schools of thought: first, an approach that emphasizes the unconditional implementation of hadd punishment; second, a view that calls for the abolition or suspension of the implementation of the punishment; and third, a detailed approach that distinguishes between different cases based on the type of crime or stage of the proceedings. The evaluation of the Islamic Penal Code of 2013 shows that the legislator, with a moderate and expedient approach, has provided for the suspension or postponement of the execution of the sentence instead of the forced fall of the punishment. The research findings indicate that subsequent insanity, despite not affecting the nature of criminal liability, is considered a religious and legal obstacle to the execution of the punishment until the recovery of sanity and the ability to defend; an interpretation that is most in line with the principles of fair trial and the foundations of human rights.

Analysis the Criminal Policy of the Criteria-Based Pardon Circular 2025

Pages 97-126

https://doi.org/10.22034/law.2026.738412

Mahdi Saboori Pour, Omidreza Farokhdoust

Abstract The institution of pardon within Iran's criminal justice system, as one of the instruments of executive criminal policy, has in recent years transcended its traditional function as a manifestation of sovereign mercy and has evolved into a regulatory mechanism for managing the penal population. In this context, the Criteria-Based Pardon Circular issued by the Head of the Judiciary in September 2025 introduces a novel approach to granting pardons to convicts, grounded in objective and transparent criteria. Adopting a descriptive-analytical method and proceeding from the fundamental premise that pardon constitutes an instrument of criminal policy, this study seeks to evaluate the aforementioned circular. The aim of this research is to conduct a systematic analysis of the circular from a criminal policy perspective, in order to elucidate its objectives, scope of impact, innovations, and potential tensions. From this standpoint, the study may play a significant role in informing future policy-making. The central research question is: which model of criminal policy does the Criteria-Based Circular of 2025 reflect within Iran's criminal justice system, and what policy-oriented distinctions does this standardized pardon exhibit in comparison with previous practices? The findings indicate that this comprehensive pardon, rather than being predicated upon judicial individualization, is primarily governed by the logic of managerialism in criminal justice. By distinguishing low-risk offences from security-related and major economic crimes, the Criteria-Based Circular reflects a hybrid model combining a differential, lenient approach with an authoritarian one. The broad inclusion of convicts—encompassing both intentional and unintentional offenders—underscores the objective of reducing prison overcrowding and controlling the costs of the criminal justice system.

Jurisprudential and legal review of the judgment of the client's legal and material possessions Before receiving intercession

Pages 127-148

https://doi.org/10.22034/law.2026.740777

Majid Arefali, Mohammad Farzanegan

Abstract The interpretation of Article 816 of the Civil Code that "... shall be void" as the effect of intercession in the validity of customer transactions has become a source of disagreement among jurists, as to how a valid transaction becomes a void transaction from the first day of its conclusion. Will it be?! How can the regressive effect of receiving shafea be combined with the accuracy of the customer's possessions? By looking at the jurisprudential records, including the possibility of annulment from the first day of the contract, or its rescission, together with other rulings in the civil law itself, including the validity of the buyer's legal possessions or his ownership of separate interests from the date of the sale to the acceptance of the intercession. The theory of canceling such contracts seems more compatible with the existing legal system and rules. In the matter of material possessions, the two assumptions of the impropriety of the buyer's material possession of the property subject to protection and its permissibility are separated from each other, and in the first case, the buyer is obliged to take possession of the property and agriculture, without the right to receive compensation. However, in the second assumption, despite the buyer's right to dispose of his properties by owning them, if the properties include buildings and trees, there is a possibility of removing them by the intercessor, because taking the intercession causes ownership of the seller by the intercessor.

A look at the approaches of terrorist groups from the perspective of criminal psychology data With an emphasis on brainwashing organs

Pages 150-179

https://doi.org/10.22034/law.2026.743292

Seyyed MohammadReza Mousavi Fard, Narjes Saryar

Abstract In addition to external crimes against Public Security, terrorist groups also treat their members with evil behavior, the most important and complex of which is brainwashing. This phenomenon, which practically deprives a person of the possibility of voluntary return, is considered an unforgivable crime in the balance of International Criminal Law. The author has explored the psychological and legal dimensions of this problem in the leading research with a descriptive-analytical approach and the use of documentary and library resources.The findings show that terrorist groups, by exploiting psychological vulnerabilities, feelings of deprivation, the need for identity and belonging, as well as a model of charismatic leadership, provide a platform for absolute attraction and loyalty of members. The brainwashing process in these groups is usually achieved through interconnected strategies: forgetting the past through manipulation of key brain areas such as the hippocampus and amygdala, forced mental control using new neuroscience technologies, forced persuasion based on hidden strategies of social influence, undermining the system of critical thinking through repeated induction and targeted propaganda, and finally re-education and absolute adherence to group values. These stages occur so intertwined and gradual that a person is trapped in imposed beliefs before any knowledge. At the end of the abstract, we believe that the international criminal liability for the leaders of these groups, The Independent criminalization of this action within the framework of non-international armed conflicts, and the identification of civil liability for the families of the victims have been proposed as effective measures to protect the rights of members and prevent the recurrence of such crimes.